Commentary by Charles Coxhead

Charles Coxhead - Vice President, New Zealand

Leading the New Zealand Netconcepts office Charles brings a wealth of sales and marketing experience with a particular focus on building businesses on the web. He has lead the development and implementation of web based solutions for Fortune 500 corporations in Australia and the US, marketed New Zealand’s favorite travel site, houseoftravel.co.nz , and developed a number of web properties focused around blogs, web publishing and RSS.

Google [not so] Local

Checkout this search query on Google.co.nz….

electrician in Birkenhead

Searching on google.co.nz, selecting pages from New Zealand, and using a query which makes it pretty clear what I am looking for, you’d think Google would know which set of local results to show. Notice anything wrong?

I’m sure Birkenhead in Merseyside (UK) is a lovely place, but it is about 12,000miles from where I am interested in, namely Birkenhead, Auckland. Here’s the screenshot:

click to enlarge

google_local_result

Thankfully local business directories Finda and Yellow are ranking strongly :)

test

Search and Brand Marketing

search and brand marketing

[an abbreviated version of this article first appeared in the Febuary issue of Admedia magazine]

Let me state at the outset that I am a card-carrying member of the direct response school of search marketing, an unapologetic advocate for spending more on search and less on everything else. I got this way because I was responsible for making a return on online marketing budgets and over time I found that search consistently delivered the results. Simple.

Except it isn’t actually that simple. Over time I have also come to realise that brand plays an enormously important role in search marketing ,and as the web consumes an ever greater share of our media diet that search can play a big role in growing brands as well. In fact, I would go as far as saying that today search and brand marketing are inextricably linked and to ignore one or the other is not only missing an opportunity but doing your business a great disservice. Let’s explore …

The case for search

It hardly seems necessary to talk about how important search is in the mix today. We all know that the internet is eating more and more of our time. We all know that search is the window on the web.

Search engines are not only how we search for stuff, they are also how we navigate the web. Think about your own behaviour. I’m willing to bet that your browser start page is a search engine or has a search box on it and if not then you probably have one or more of those search engine toolbars installed so the search box is never far away.

It makes sense too. With 60,000,000,000+ pages online you need a way around.

Important for marketers is the big  role search plays throughout the buying process. Performix, a division of Doubleclick, did a study which showed that 55% of all consumer purchases in certain verticals were influenced by the use of search engines. Whether buying in-store or online, consumers are using search engines to research information on products and services.

Yahoo’s search marketing team has also done some interesting research. Contrary to popular misconception, they  found that search is not just about the direct response and the last click – in their study, half of the recorded search activity resulted in an online purchase some 30 days later, while just 15% resulted in a direct response. Search plays a role throughout the buying cycle.

Brand vs non-brand

At the heart of search marketing is the keyword query. When it comes to keywords there is an important distinction to be made between branded keywords and non-brand keywords. The former is obvious, these are keyword queries focused on, or including, your brand name (ie, ‘Apple iPod’).

The latter are all the generic unbranded keywords and phrases related to the products or services you sell (e.g. ‘mp3 player’), and there may be literally thousands of keyword combinations and permutations for any given market, which search marketers call the ‘long tail’ of search.

The thing about branded keyword queries is that these people have already formed a brand preference. They already know who you are and what you do. Depending on where they are in the buying cycle (and the nature of the market you are in) they might not be searching at all, but rather navigating. If I search for ‘Rebel Sports’ or ‘16gb Apple iPod Touch’ it is pretty clear what I am looking for.

So whether you are trying to rank in natural search results or launching a paid search campaign, brand-related search queries represent an opportunity to reach people who have stated a preference for your brand. Thankfully the search engines are generally very good at figuring out which brand belongs to which website so normally it is a no-brainer to rank well in the natural search results for branded queries. If you are not ranking naturally for your own brand then you need to have a deep and meaningful with  your web team.

Keep in mind though that branded terms represent the small part of the pie. Sure, the top 100 search terms of all time are mostly brands, but that misses the point of the long tail – there are many more long tail/non-brand terms in any given market and in aggregate they represent much more latent opportunity.

Going back to the Yahoo! Search Marketing research, they also studied the type of keywords being used throughout the buying process. They found that 70% of all the keywords used by consumers throughout the buying process were generic non-brand queries.

This study showed that over a recorded 12-week buying cycle the mix of brand to non-brand keywords evolved as you would expect. As people researched the purchase over time they formed stronger brand preferences and the number of branded queries increased. But most interestingly, the generic non-brand keywords still made up over 70% of the demand in total.

Imagine then what it means not to show up in search results for the generic/non-brand keyword queries in this particular market. You would be missing out on 70% of the search traffic. That 70% by the way is all people who have not yet formed a specific brand preference; they are researching and looking for information which is going to influence their purchase decision.

Thinking about your own business, what are the obvious generic keywords in your market? What are the less obvious long tail keywords in your market? Are you ranking for those today, or bidding on those terms in a paid search campaign? And what would it mean for your brand if people consistently found your brand and products showing up for those important generic keyword phrases?

This is my argument for the role of search in building brands. If you are in the business of selling jeans it is very powerful to show up for the keyword query ‘jeans’, or more specifically ‘womens jeans’ or ‘designer jeans’ or ‘skinny jeans’ (I hear they’re the thing right now).

Such generic keyword queries represent a huge volume of people researching and shopping, certainly more than are searching on your brand itself. And these are the people who haven’t necessarily formed a strong brand preference. They are the people you most need to reach and by showing up for these keyword queries you have the opportunity to position your brand with consumers who are looking for the products you sell.

How brands influence searcher behaviour

I did also say that brands have an important influence on search marketing too. By this I mean that brands certainly impact searcher behaviour. All other things being equal, well known and trusted brands are most likely to attract the click on a search result page. Just like any channel, people will be influenced by their brand awareness and preferences. If your brand is well known and you rank for those non-brand keywords it not only drives qualified traffic but consistently reinforces your brand in the minds of consumers.

This has implications for the way we build our web presence and implement our search marketing campaign, both for natural search and paid search campaigns. The opportunity is to leverage the long tail of generic non-brand keyword queries, but in such a way as to promote and leverage our brand which continues to be very important for all the reasons brand marketers can probably articulate much better than me.

It’s all about intent

Ever wondered why Google (the company) is so valuable? It’s because they know what people want, literally. At no other time do people flag a more specific intent than when they perform a keyword search. Google (and the others) have figured out how to build a market around that signal of intent in the form of their respective advertising platforms.

Every time someone, anyone, does a search Google is essentially auctioning off that signal of intent to the highest bidder. Of course it is a little more subtle than that, but that’s the basic opportunity of a paid search campaign.

Equally the natural (non-paid) search results represent an opportunity to position your brand for relevant unbranded product-related keyword queries. Google & co will rank your site in the natural search results for given keywords based on algorithmic meritocracy, which means that your site ranks where it deserves to rank. Of course that begs an obvious question. Answer this and you’ll understand what the opportunity is for your brand in natural search.

I believe that brand and search marketing are complementary sciences and that there’s a big opportunity for savvy brand marketers to position their brands though search in the most powerful way, right at the moment that potential customers are putting up their hand and telling you what they want.

Search Marketing is growing fast in NZ, but we are still spending much less on search (paid and natural) than marketers in Europe, North America and Australia. Locally some industries, like travel, have been quick to capitalise on search as part of the mix, but in many others there is still an opportunity to take a leadership position.

test

We’re Hiring

We have a position to fill here in our Auckland office for a Senior Search Marketing Consultant…read on if you are interested.

This is the job ad I just posted on Seek:

Senior Search Marketing Consultant

Netconcepts is looking for an SEO & SEM expert to join our team in Auckland as a Senior Search Marketing Consultant. This is an important role in our business where you will be responsible for managing client facing engagements, deliverables, and ultimately accountable for results. You will be very comfortable presenting at senior levels and delegating work through our team of search analysts as required.

Who We Are…

Netconcepts is a multinational search marketing agency with offices in the US, Auckland and Beijing. We have over 13 years experience delivering online solutions, particularly search engine optimisation, search engine advertising,  and web development to some of Australasia’s most successful organisations including Air New Zealand, The AA, Orca, RealEstate.co.nz and Expedia Inc.

Who We’re Looking For…

  • Digital native who spends as much time living online as we do. You probably blog, you definitely Twitter and while you don’t like the term “SMM” you get what it means for search and online marketing.
  • Demonstrable expertise in SEO (2-3 yrs experience min.)
  • Adwords qualified (2-3yrs experience)
  • Excellent spoken and written English (we’ll want you to contribute to our blog)
  • Generally a cool guy or gal who we’ll like working with and who will represent us really well.

Where You’ll Be Working…

This position is based in our Auckland office located in sunny Browns Bay, while you will be working with clients in Auckland and on the east coast of Australia (occasional travel required). You’ll predominantly work with the local team here, but will also interface with our offices in the US and Beijing.

What we have to offer…

  • Competitive package ~ $70-80k
  • A tight team and flat company structure…makes it more fun
  • A reputation for excellence in search marketing
  • The opportunity to work on some big search projects with interesting clients
  • Unique technology in the Australasian market
  • A table tennis table!

If you are interested please give me a call…Charles @ (09) 476 4601

test

Free Wordpress Theme

There’s loads of places to find free Wordpress themes, the best is probably the official Wordpress Theme Gallery. You name a topic and there is undoubtedly a royalty free theme available to suit.

Our own talented studio head, Karen Rubado, designed this theme for the Online Marketer blog, and we figured we might as well make it available for others to use too…

Download Online Marketer Wordpress Theme

Here’s a screenshot:

We have a few customizations live on this site which we’ve had to remove from this distribution so that it will play nicely with an out of the box install of Wordpress, but we hope you’ll agree it is a nice, simple, and clean theme…and of course it is pretty well optimized for SEO :)

Installation Instructions:

  1. Download the zip file and extract the contents
  2. Upload the extracted folder to the /wp-content/themes/ folder
  3. Log into your Wordpress admin, navigate to the Design administration section and select the Online Marketer theme
  4. Go and make a cup of tea to celebrate because you are all done

Leave a comment here if you have any questions. We’ll try to answer them as best we can, but please understand that we can’t promise to provide installation or customization support beyond informal Q&A :)

test

When the going gets tough…

Just last might I was reflecting to a friend that we had been unexpectedly busy recently with lots of enquiries, proposals and statements of work going out the door, many of them related to search marketing and SEO in particular. Then this morning I read Rand Fishkin’s post over at SEOmoz:

In the last 6 weeks, SEOmoz has received a higher than normal volume of requests for consulting. Alongside that, we’ve been getting calls from venture capital firms out of the blue - seven to date - asking either about investments they’re considering in the SEO sphere (and requesting insight) or literally asking whether SEOmoz would like to take more capital to grow (post about that coming soon). And it’s not just us. The jobs and contracts section of the Marketplace has been humming in November, and anecdotal conversations with other SEO firms tell me there’s quite a bit of business to be had for both in-house and external SEOs.

Read the full post: Why Companies are Investing in SEO During the Economic Downturn

One thing that really rings true for me is his point about interest in SEO being driven by paid search marketing. With the ROI on PPC being so immediate and accountable it is only natural for Marketing Managers to start asking about the other 70% of search queries which don’t result in a click on a paid listing. How good would it be for your business if you could rank top 10 for those?

test

Marketing is an Art and a Science

This post over at Idealog caught my attention this morning…

Google chief executive Eric Schmidt told a recent Advertising Age conference that the future of advertising lies in measurement. But, to quote the genius campaign for Toyota’s Signature range of imported used cars: they would say that.

It would be easy to assume that Google is utterly unbiased—the numbers don’t lie, after all. But data (gathered after the event) doesn’t necessarily amount to intelligence.

If Google is right we will have gone from one extreme to the other. Rampant idealism meets bloodless statistics.

read the full article

The point I think David MacGregor is making is that marketing and advertising are not just about statistics, and that we should not let Google’s algorithmic approach to what they do vanillify marketing practice. And I have to say that I agree in large part…marketing is about people and when it comes to people there’s always more art than science imho.

But marketing and advertising is an art in the conception and the execution (just like business generally). Google are pioneering ways to execute better but I don’t think that necessarily means there isn’t still plenty of scope for well conceived advertising creative.

Even in Google’s Adwords product there’s a need for creativity and persuasion. For sure it is very a limited medium, but good ‘creative’ copy in search marketing can move ROI + or - an enormous amount. And Google’s Adwords product isn’t just about what you do to get the click, that’s only half the job (or less), what happens after the click is probably more important…enter stage left talented marketers.

So, I would argue that Google’s algorithmic approach doesn’t reduce the need or importance of good creative marketing and advertising (the big idea!), but does bring some long overdue science to the execution. Measurement is really important. Particularly as the economy tightens good marketers want to know where the ROI is.

But then again, I’m a dyed in the wool search marketer so I would say that :)

test

Blended Search

This article also appears in the September edition of NZ Marketing magazine

What is search engine optimisation? The usual reply is “oh, that’s placing keywords on the homepage of your website”. Truth is there is much more involved in optimising a website, and it is goes well beyond just the words on your pages.  Indeed, where the end goal is to generate qualified traffic to a website to reach marketing objectives it does not necessarily mean that only your website needs to be optimised.

The term “Blended Search” represents the various online media and search products that can be found in search results today. Traditional web search is only one product offered by search engines. Other search media include images, video, news, people, maps, documents, directories, books and blogs.

The major search engines including Google, Yahoo! and MSN Live now display different search media within their search results with the intention of offering more “diversity of opinion”.  They take into account more than one source of opinion by including media forms such as news or video content that contain information about a specific topic.

By way of example try searching for the term “darth vader” in Google.com. Blended within search results are website pages, images, blog posts, micro blog posts (Twitter), YouTube video, wiki entries and more. Or closer to home, try search for “Auckland hotels”, the very first result is a map of Auckland with links to various Hotel sites.

If search engines are now favouring diversity of opinion and news, video or images will be included within search results, doesn’t that mean that those media should also be optimised to be found easily online? Absolutely!

Natural search marketing is about optimising and raising the visibility of all online media assets in search engines, and other relevant sites (Flickr.com or YouTube.com for example). Brand owners now need to look beyond their own website and consider the other media types that are available and how to best incorporate them into their full optimisation strategy.

Maybe a Twitter strategy [a form of micro blogging] is not suitable for all companies, but marketers can certainly find other online media types that are relevant to their line of business.

Blended search strategies do not necessarily mean new content needs to be created for the web, indeed many companies will have a range of existing offline media assets that could be easily repurposed for the Internet. It is rather a matter of optimizing all web assets to ensure that they can be found online to raise brand awareness and drive new traffic to your website.

And the mainstream search engines are not the only sources of qualified traffic. It seems everyone is jumping into video these days on the back of YouTube’s success, and as this space gets more competitive, it becomes necessary to optimise your assets if you expect to rank well for relevant keyword queries.
For example, if you search for the competitive term “travel auckland” in YouTube NZ, at the time of writing there were only 350 listings.  The first page of results contains 8 listings from a particular travel agency, “Kapai Travel Auckland New Zealand,” out of 20 possible results. This is a small business that has done a good job of gaining visibility for this term. Larger players such as House of Travel or Flight Centre do rank well for their brand terms, but do not appear in any listings relating to destination terms such as “travel auckland”.

The emergence of blended search results creates challenges for marketers as the business of optimising content for search engines has becoming increasingly complex. Where previously a website may have enjoyed certain rankings, the introduction other media such as video, maps and images may well push those results further down the page.

Search is at the heart of all online media and the onus is now on marketers to implement strategies which maximise the value of these assets in search engines like Google and Yahoo, but also in the results of destination media sites like YouTube (the 3rd most visited non-search site in the world). This means taking a systematic approach to optimising all your web assets so to maximize their value.

test

Online Retail Seminar Series

I just got back from a really great seminar series organized by e-retail consultant Cate Bryant under the auspices of the New Zealand Retailers Association. It was a great event with fantastic presentations from Grant Jennings of Ezibuy and Vikki Branagan, former CEO of Stevens. Sailesh Manga (of Optimal Usability), Cate, and myself also did some site reviews of well known Kiwi eCommerce sites as well as some on the fly assessments of sites volunteered by attendees. The event was held over three days in Auckland, Wellington, and Christchurch and I think was genuinely useful for all the attendees. If you are in the business of online retail I would recommend looking for the next in this series which will feature a talk by Will Hunsinger, ex VP of Gap online in the US.

A couple of takeways for me related to the use of Rich Internet Applications (RIAs) in the online retail space, which was something the Ezibuy team talked to, and also the idea of Gift Giving as an online retail strategy which is what Vikki Branagan talked about. I’ll be following up with some posts reflecting on both these soon.

test

If you are interested in search…

Just a quick one to point out this post on the official Google blog by one of their ‘Google Fellows’, Amit Singhal. Of course it doesn’t dive too deep, but it is a good read if you are interested in the way Google works. I also find it interesting because it seems to signal an intent to be a bit more communicative with the marketplace…

As part of our effort to discuss search quality, I want to tell you more about the technologies behind our ranking. The core technology in our ranking system comes from the academic field of Information Retrieval (IR)…read more.

The post goes on to talk about one of my favorite topics, searcher intent, but one of the take aways for me was the reminder that Google not only has to solve the problem of indexing and understanding the content of pages on the web, but they also have to solve the problem of understanding search queries, which might be mispelled, have double meanings or be otherwise non-specific. Amit gives some great examples to illustrate these.

test

So Flash is now indexable…

flash.jpgBig news broke in the search engine world last week…Flash files (.swf) can now be indexed by the major search engines. Flash developers will be rejoicing, but at the risk of being a killjoy I’m not sure this is really worthy of celebrating…

The news broke last week, but honestly it feels like more of a PR exercise for Adobe than any real break though in the search friendliness of Flash. Our recommendation is still to use Flash only for rich media, and leave content and navigation to HTML, which will always do a better job.

The announcement actually opens more questions than provides answers, and here’s a few reasons to remain cautious…

  • If you use JavaScript to display your flash movie you’ll still be invisible. Try visiting pepsi.com with JavaScript turned off to see what I mean.
  • The text and links in a Flash file can only be indexed if they are infact in the Flash file…which is to point out that most modern Flash is developed as a shell these days with the content called in from remote XML or HTML files. In this case the search engine may well find the content but it will not be indexed as part of the page as intended.
  • Of course if the textual content is bound up inside an image within the Flash then it will not be indexed.
  • Even if you include all your content and product information as text within the Flash file then you are still a long way from being search engine optimised. The reason each category and product on your site should have its own page is that this gives Google pages with specific focus to index…they can tell exactly what each page is about and rank them for appropriate keyword queries. If you have all your category and product information bound up in one monolithic Flash file then it may well be indexable but the page is unlikely to rank for anything much because the content provides no clear topical focus. A well constructed and organised HTML site with the same content will always out rank the Flash one.
  • And if it wasn’t clear from the last point there remains a big issue with addressability. Each discrete chunk of content on your site (be it a category or a specific product or news item) should have its own url. This is important so people can link to it, but also so Google and the other search engines can identify relevant pieces of content to rank for relevant keywords. It is possible to do this with Flash, but typically it is not done well.

I wrote this post because I shudder to think of all the Flash development that is likely to sell now with the added assurance that it is “search engine friendly”. Fact is that indexation is only one part of the puzzle and Flash still falls short in other respects.

Our advice is unchanged…by all means, use Flash for rich media, but leave the navigation and content to HTML.

If you are determined to introduce Flash to your site then make sure you follow a ‘progressive enhancement’ design paradigm. This means first developing your site using the most basic technology, ie. HTML, and then adding handlers to introduce Flash or JavaScript powered UI enhancements if they are supported by the client browser. This way you can be sure that your site will suit search engine spiders and users without the lastest Flash plugin…and for those that do have Flash they get the nice UI enhancements.

test

The changing nature of brands

I hate to blockquote so much of a great post, but if you have any interest in marketing and brand and business generally, you need to read this…

Quick – what’s the top brand in the world? Coca-Cola? Nope. IBM? Nope. One of GE’s stable of brands? Wrong again.
All these players are near the top. But the most powerful brand in the world today is, according to the gold standard of brand valuation, Millward Brown’s Brandz report, Google.

Now, that might seem superficially logical. But from a strategic point of view, it’s nothing short of astonishing. Why? Because every other player in the top ten has spent decades – if not literally centuries, as for P&G and Coke – investing billions in advertising to build a brand.

But where these players invest on the order of 5-10% of revenues on advertising, Google’s advertising expenditure is almost exactly zero.

Read the rest, it’s really good (and there’s a bonus video).

I reckon that pretty much everything we need to know about social media marketing was written back in 1999 when the Cluetrain Manifesto was published on the thesis that “markets are conversations”…

And in his post Umair Hague is reflecting something similar, that the value of traditional brand equity is fast eroding as the cost of interaction amongst consumers drops and the value of that interaction grows…in other words ‘consumers’ (aka people) would much rather talk to other consumers than consume mass media from corporations…and they can do this much more efficiently than the corporations can carpet bomb them with media.

So at the very least we all better be listening to those conversations, if not actively being part of the conversation…which if you’re reading this probably comes second nature because you are already participating, or atleast you’re about to…go on leave a comment and tell me what you think :)

UPDATE: I posted this late last night and ran out of steam a bit, but went to sleeping thinking about it and there’s definitely more to say, particularly about the challenges that traditional businesses have engaging in the conversation…I mean it isn’t like the individuals within large traditional organizations are not participating (lots are), but often those organizations do seem to have to have brand and organizational blockers which prevent effective particpation, e.g. “blog writing isn’t on anyones job description!”.

Plus it isn’t always obvious how an organization should engage in the conversation. For all the talk of social media marketing these days I really don’t think that a MySpace profile or a Facebook group is the right answer for everyone…a blog on the other hand is a great starting point and I rarely find anyone with a good reason why they shouldn’t blog.

test

Intent Driven Marketing

Google Search MarketingThere’s a reason Google’s stock price has reached such lofty heights. It’s because they know what every business wishes they could…they know what people want.

And I’m not being glib here, they really do know what people want, and not just in the “we’ve done some market research” way. What else is a search query but a signal of a searchers need, or put another way a signal of intent. Google has become so valuable because they’ve figured out how to build an advertising market around that signal of intent. Everytime someone, anyone, does a search Google is auctioning of that signal of intent to the highest bidder. Of course it is a little more subtle than that (more on that soon), but Google is basically selling each search as a unique opportunity to market to someone who has flagged a specific intent based on a keyword query.

As a marketer that’s an exciting prospect, so the amazing thing from my perspective is why New Zealand businesses have collectively been quite slow to adopt paid search marketing. Some industries have jumped in both feet (travel for example), but most are missing a big opportunity to drive highly qualified traffic to their web site. At no other moment in time do consumers flag a more specific intent than when they do a keyword search, so if you can interpret that intent, and then deliver on it, then the rewards are there for the taking. That’s why I like to think of paid search marketing (aka PPC or Adwords advertising) as ‘intent driven marketing’.

In future posts about paid search, the team will be exploring  some of the subtleties of managing an effective campaign so please make sure you subcribe to The OnlineMarketer RSS feed.

test